Hi Turnaface,
Well I am a bulky chap so I favour torque over revs, and the Benelli has a decent pull, low geared 360 crank parallel twin: Torque is what it's built for. (I've not had a 4cyl since the 90's). Also my knee doesn't favour very high seats or aggressive pegs so the cruiser stance suits me well, although the backrest sometimes gets in the way of cocking a leg. My previous bike was a R1150RS beemer, a much more expensive and theoretically a technicially superior mile-eating vehicle, but it was dull dull dull.
The 502C is an "Urban Cruiser" so quite low-geared, but it cruises Motorway Legal +30MPH with me on it, if you knew me you'd be impressed. Pottering around town with the torque / 6 speed gearbox I usually stay below 3000rpm so it's extremely frugal.
Nice wide bars, good low speed handling, relaxed riding position and swoopy handling, good build quality for the price, excellent road presence as it's not a small bike, and the only real competition for a cruiser is the Kawasaki Vulcan S 650cc. That's lower and a bit more HP, but is ugly, about ÂŁ2k more than the Benelli, and much more common. I was in line to get that model, except I stumbled across the 502C more or less by accident. The marketing is almost non existent, even though every review I've read is excellent, go figure.
I have had more compliments on the Benelli that I got when i was riding my FLHRCI RoadKing back in the day, and with a few tweaks
(Bar-end mirrors, Puig flycreen and Easylock panniers) it easily coped with a week long summer trip to Cornwall and back, and to my club's annual Bike Rally. It never missed a beat, didn't even lose tyre pressure or need oil top up. Great fun on the A roads.
I like the firm suspension for obvious reasons given my bulk, it gives excellent road feedback, some complain too much firmness in the suspension and about lightweight braking but mine seems about right (
After 30+years of riding, if I need to brake to slow down, I've done it wrong...)
Last thing to consider is that if you haven't had to buy insurance there's difference in insurance between a 499cc and a 649cc. I suppose that might be offset if you choose the more common brand.
Whichever bike you choose, I heartily recommend getting back on the road, I have no regrets at all
(Not sure I'd would be able to say that if I'd bought the Vulcan
....)